Monday, August 31, 2009
Hockey Players Oust Director With Input From Ombuds
New Canadian Banking Ombuds Named
Related post: Canadian Banking Ombuds Releases Year-End Review.
21 Recommended ADR Blogs
Sunday, August 30, 2009
Handling a Tyrant Boss
Tantrums
• Determine the best time of day and day of the week to approach your TOT;
• Don't hang around for the fireworks or engage;
• Keep CALM -- Communicate, Anticipate, Laugh, and Manage;
Demanding
• Set expectations through regular meetings;
• Let your TOT know when you are feeling overwhelmed and use priority task lists;
• Communicate when a project has been successful;
Needy
• Encourage your TOT's independence and reinforce her own competence;
• Offer a plan to cover excessive workloads;
• Help your boss learn that other people can serve her as well;
Stubborn
• Use positive language to relax your stubborn TOT;
• Know that it's easier for TOTs to be more flexible if there's something in it for them;
• Offer choices and compromises that empower your TOT;
Distracted
• Make communications compelling;
• Use props, visual aids, and humor to keep your manager engaged and on target;
• Manage interruptions.
These tips and Taylor's book, Tame Your Terrible Office Tyrant (TOT): How to Manage Childish Boss Behavior and Thrive in Your Job, will be valuable for many Ombuds' visitors. (Business Week; Tame Your Tot Blog.)
Related posts: When the Boss is a Bully or Jerk; Opinion of Boss Drives Most Decisions to Quit.
Saturday, August 29, 2009
Study Shows That Ridicule Undermines Workplace Performance
More science confirming common sense.
Friday, August 28, 2009
Harvard University Ombuds to Take on Public Safety Issues
In her newly expanded role, Cummings will meet with the Safety Advisory Committee, review and recommend resolutions to general and specific concerns raised by members of the University community, and bring any systemic issues to the attention of the administration, when warranted. To ensure that community members know where to bring issues, the office’s expanded role will be communicated on the Harvard College Web site, in the Handbook for Students, in House newsletters, in the Freshman Newsletter, and through the residential deans.
(Harvard News; Boston Globe.)
Ombuds as Antidote to Rising Threat of Litigation in Academia
Gajda does offer some hope. In an interview with the Chronicle of Higher Education, she says:
[C]olleges and universities need to build a stronger sense of community on campus. By this I mean an inclusive, open, diverse community with open channels of communication and effective means of addressing disputes internally. If students, faculty, administrators, and staff are divided by a sense of detachment or mutual suspicion, we can expect to see more litigation. Offering alternatives through campus mediation, ombudspersons, and the like can help to defuse conflicts and keep them out of court.
Her book is scheduled for release in October. (Harvard University Press; Chronicle of Higher Ed.)
Thursday, August 27, 2009
Camosun College Ombuds Fights Firing
Two Former Ombuds Emerge as Contenders for LAPD Chief Post
Wednesday, August 26, 2009
The Bermuda Triangle
The "Bermuda Triangle" or "Devil's Triangle" is an imaginary area located off the southeastern Atlantic coast of the United States of America, which is noted for a supposedly high incidence of unexplained disappearances of ships and aircraft. The apexes of the triangle are generally believed to be Bermuda; Miami, Florida; and San Juan, Puerto Rico. The US Board of Geographic Names does not recognize the Bermuda Triangle as an official name. The US Navy does not believe the Bermuda Triangle exists. It is reported that Lloyd's of London, the world's leading market for specialist insurance, does not charge higher premiums for vessels transiting this heavily traveled area.
The most famous US Navy losses which have occurred in the area popularly known as the Bermuda Triangle are USS Cyclops in March 1918 and the aircraft of Flight 19 in December 1945. The ship probably sank in an unexpected storm, and the aircraft ran out of fuel and crashed into the ocean -- no physical traces of them have ever been found. Another well known disappearance is the civilian tanker SS Marine Sulphur Queen carrying bulk molten sulfur which sank in February 1963. Although the wreck of Marine Sulphur Queen has not been located, a life preserver and other floating artifacts were recovered. These disappearances have been used to provide credence to the popular belief in the mystery and purported supernatural qualities of the "Bermuda Triangle."
Since the days of early civilization many thousands of ships have sunk and/or disappeared in waters around the world due to navigational and other human errors, storms, piracy, fires, and structural/mechanical failures. Aircraft are subject to the same problems, and many of them have crashed at sea around the globe. Often, there were no living witnesses to the sinking or crash, and hence the exact cause of the loss and the location of the lost ship or aircraft are unknown. A large number of pleasure boats travel the waters between Florida and the Bahamas. All too often, crossings are attempted with too small a boat, insufficient knowledge of the area's hazards, and a lack of good seamanship.
To see how common accidents are at sea, you can examine some of the recent accident reports of the National Transportation Safety Board for ships and aircraft. One of the aircraft accident reports concerns an in-flight engine failure and subsequent ditching of a Cessna aircraft near Great Abaco Island in the Bahamas on 13 July 2003. This is the type of accident that would likely have been attributed to mysterious causes in the Bermuda Triangle if there had been no survivors or other eyewitnesses of the crash.
A significant factor with regard to missing vessels in the Bermuda Triangle is a strong ocean current called the Gulf Stream. It is extremely swift and turbulent and can quickly erase evidence of a disaster. The weather also plays its role. Prior to the development of telegraph, radio and radar, sailors did not know a storm or hurricane was nearby until it appeared on the horizon. For example, the Continental Navy sloop Saratoga was lost off the Bahamas in such a storm with all her crew on 18 March 1781. Many other US Navy ships have been lost at sea in storms around the world. Sudden local thunder storms and water spouts can sometimes spell disaster for mariners and air crews. Finally, the topography of the ocean floor varies from extensive shoals around the islands to some of the deepest marine trenches in the world. With the interaction of the strong currents over the many reefs the topography of the ocean bottom is in a state of flux and the development of new navigational hazards can sometimes be swift.
It has been inaccurately claimed that the Bermuda Triangle is one of the two places on earth at which a magnetic compass points towards true north. Normally a compass will point toward magnetic north. The difference between the two is known as compass variation. The amount of variation changes by as much as 60 degrees at various locations around the World. If this compass variation or error is not compensated for, navigators can find themselves far off course and in deep trouble. Although in the past this compass variation did affect the "Bermuda Triangle" region, due to fluctuations in the Earth's magnetic field this has apparently not been the case since the nineteenth century.
Ombuds Training in North Carolina
- Ombudsman 101 (Oct. 26-28): An introductory program for new Ombudsman or those seeking information about the organizational Ombudsman role.
- Ombudsman 101 Plus (Oct. 28): A special program for organizations and entrepreneurs who want to get started.
- Specialized Course: Conflict Resolution (Oct. 29): This course is designed to view conflict as an opportunity to make us more effective as agents of positive change, primarily in the workplace, but in other settings as well.
- Specialized Course: Trust and the Ombudsman Process (Oct. 30): This course will explore the importance and development of trust throughout the Ombudsman Process, including working with the initiator, the respondent and the organization.
Monday, August 24, 2009
Boston University Selects First Ombuds
Related posts: Notes on the IOA Annual (2007) Conference; Job Posting: Boston University.
Sunday, August 23, 2009
Leaked Document Reveals Work of College Ombuds
Written by an anonymous Grinnell faculty member in about December 2008, the leaked document reveals a covert investigation that found similar problems during the administrator's prior appointment at Lewis & Clark College. Fortunately, Lewis & Clark had an Ombuds who was able to assist, much to the relief of the administration at Lewis & Clark. According the the leaked document:
The Need for an OmbudspersonOf course, but for the leaked document, the work of the Lewis & Clark Ombuds would have remained secret and known only to a few. The Grinnell faculty has apparently realized the value of an Ombuds and has created a Faculty Governance Group to look into the creation of a Ombuds office for the campus. (Grinnell Faculty Meeting Minutes, 4/6/09.)
In her written statement, the retired director also notes, "After [the administrator] left, the division required counseling and intervention with an organizational rescuer. We needed this. It amazes me what one person can do in 18 months." A high level administrator at L&C, with whom Ralph spoke, and who is willing to speak to our trustees privately, confirms this account. The college's ombudsperson (at L&C the ombudsperson is a totally independent conflict-resolution agent) interviewed every member of the ... division at the new dean's request and then did periodic follow-ups. The administrator reported that the "entire division was a basket case. Valerie [the ombudsperson] was needed to heal us. (Full text pdf, p. 4.)
Related post: Lewis & Clark College Launches Ombuds Office.
Correction 8/26/09: The original version of this post mistakenly indicated that mistakenly asserted that the administrator had left Grinnell College. In fact, the administrator still serves in that position. I apologize for the error.
Update 3/30/10: The post was amended to remove details identifying Grinnell's senior administrator. One comment that lead to the correction on 8/26/09 was also removed. These details were peripheral to the issue of the Ombuds role in the underlying matter.
Friday, August 21, 2009
Profile of New Ombuds at Washington & Lee
Reid earned her BA in history from the University of Vermont and an ME from Northern Arizona University. She is completing PhD in conflict analysis and resolution from NOVA Southeastern University. Reid developed and directed the Ombuds program at Central Arizona College in the 1990’s. A faculty member at Eastern Mennonite University since 2006, Reid became the director of EMU’s mediation, facilitation and job-coaching program for faculty, staff and students in 2007. She also teaches introduction to conflict transformation at Bridgewater College, in Bridgewater, Va. (Rockbridge Weekly.)
Related post: Washington & Lee Unveils Ombuds Office.
Thursday, August 20, 2009
OO Blogger: The "New Ombudsman"
First, the “new ombudsman” is a progressive philosopher and an eclectic thinker. They are most likely a “boomer”, born of the 60’s movements and now, today, wise to the ways to not only live peacefully, but able to articulate, “practice what they preach” and technically translate education, knowledge and wisdom into a “new profession” to the benefit of others. Yes, some are lawyers, some are psychologists, some are social workers, teachers, retired from the profession they now “mediate” to; it’s an “inclusive” mix of professions and people. They didn’t know it, but looking back on their career and life they were using “ombudsmanship” all along and now want to make it their calling. They are technologically savvy, can grasp and get a handle on complex (Gordian Knot) circumstances and issues, they can do mental analysis faster than a computer, they are skilled “generalists” in their life and profession, their degrees and certificates are “translatable and applicable” in terms of value towards peace making regardless of what “others” tell them and they know it and are not deterred.
(Organizational Ombudsman Blog.)
This is an insightful and accurate portrait of the profession.
Prior posts: Clayton Gilman.
Wednesday, August 19, 2009
University of Hawaii Chancellor Clarifies Decision to Shutter Ombuds Office
To the Editor:
As the Honolulu Star-Bulletin reported on August 13, the University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa regrets that budget reductions necessitate the closure of our Ombuds Office. We wish to clarify that UHM had intended to continue the efforts of the Ombuds Office after Neal Milner's departure. Had the budgetary issues not arisen, it was anticipated that Susan Park, who currently serves as the UHM Ombuds, would have taken leadership of the Office. Unfortunately, as we have stated, current fiscal realities facing UH Mānoa limit our abilities to support the program.
Yours truly,
Virginia S. Hinshaw
UH Mānoa Chancellor
(Via email from Gregg Takayama, UH Manoa Director of Community and Government Affairs.)
Prior post: Budget Cuts Force Closure of University of Hawaii Ombuds Office.
Sunday, August 16, 2009
IOA 2010 Conference Call for Proposals
Thursday, August 13, 2009
Washington & Lee Unveils Ombuds Office
Wednesday, August 12, 2009
Budget Cuts Force Closure of University of Hawaii Ombuds Office
The office has employed three Ombuds, Neal Milner, Susan Park and Jen Graf, and one staff person, Lori Mina, since it was established in 2006. Milner, Park and Graf were active in IOA committees and conferences, and the UH Ombuds website was recently upgraded.
Related posts: University of Hawaii Touts Ombuds Office as Campus Safety Resource; U. Hawaii Ombuds Office Co-Sponsors Program on Organizational Change; University of Hawaii Releases Annual Report; New Websites Offer Resources for Ombuds.
Update 8/13/09: One Hawaiian blogger remarks:
Well there goes a useful service to UH Manoa’s community! Try to avoid having things on your mind that may bother you.
And may I remind everyone that this yahoo [Greg McMackin] makes a million bucks a year to coach UH Manoa’s Football Team?
(O/S Hawaii.)
Pelco Creates Ombuds Program
New Model for Describing How Law Schools View ADR Courses
Some law schools may become Islands of ADR—ones in which ADR is part of the school’s distinctiveness. Some law schools may ADR as Vitamins—requiring every student to take at least the recommended dosage. Some law schools may treat ADR as Salt—vital seasoning for many different offerings, but never consumed on its own. Finally, individual faculty members at some law schools may intentionally, but quietly, incorporate ADR as Germs into their courses.
The article will be published in the Ohio State Journal of Dispute Resolution and is available from SSRN. (Islands, Vitamins, Salt, Germs: Four Visions of the Future of Adr in Law Schools (and a Data-Driven Snapshot of the Field Today), via ADR Prof Blog.)
Tuesday, August 11, 2009
Federal Court Orders Production of Ombuds Records From IBM
After filing suit, API and Pinstripe sought to compel production of the report by IBM's Ombuds. IBM objected on the grounds of attorney-client and attorney work product privileges. In evaluating these arguments, the court characterized the role of the IBM Ombuds using the standards enunciated by the American Bar Association:
Generally, an ombudsman works outside of normal line management structures and directly to upper management. An ombudsman is not an advocate for the complainant, nor is his role to defend the corporation he works for. His role is that of an impartial neutral, seeking the best resolution of the dispute.
The court therefore concluded that the the primary purpose for which the documents were created was not anticipation of litigation, but a separate business purpose (fostering more a open, effective, and productive relationship with suppliers). In addition, the court observed that any of the Ombuds documents do not appear to contain communications seeking legal advice. The court therefore ordered IBM to produce most of the materials produced by its Ombuds. IBM did not raise any other legal arguments that would have protected the Ombuds' work. (Accounting Principals, Inc. v. Manpower, Inc., 07-cv-636-TCK-PJC, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 66428 (N.D. Okla. July 28, 2009) and Pinstripe, Inc. v. Manpower, Inc., 07-cv-620-GKF-PJC, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 66430 (N.D. Okla. July 28, 2009); Tulsa World; see also summary at Mayer Brown.)
Texas Ombuds to Consider Governance Issues
Monday, August 10, 2009
DC Council Pulls Plug on Schools Ombuds After Less Than Two Years
The DCPS Ombuds Office debuted in January 2008 with support from the Mayor and community. After a protracted job search, Tonya Vidal Kinlow, a former DC school board member and lobbyist, was appointed the first Ombuds for public education. She hired three staff members and began issuing monthly reports in August 2008. Although Kinlow was criticized from slow and irregular reporting, her office managed a growing caseload. Kinlow left unexpectedly in December 2008 and was succeeded by Interim Ombuds Jeff Ross. The DCPS Ombuds office will wrap up operations and close by the end of September 2009.
Prior posts: DC Mayor's School Plan Includes Ombuds; Despite Some Council Concerns, Mayor Continues to Back Ombuds for DC Schools; Job Posting: DC Schools Ombuds; DC Council to Consider Public Schools Ombuds; More Details Emerge Regarding DC School Ombuds; DC Schools Struggle to Hire Ombuds; DC Schools Appoint First Ombuds; DC Schools Ombuds Reports on Progress; DC Schools Ombuds Reports Growing Case Load; DC Schools Ombuds Lasts Just 14 Months; DC Schools Appoints Interim Ombuds; Local Politics Threaten DC Schools Ombuds; Washington Post Conflates Ombuds Reporting Line With Neutrality; Budget Deficit Threatens DC Schools Ombuds.
Article on University of Miami Ombuds Program
Related posts: Interim Ombuds at U Miami; Two New Ombuds at University of Miami.
Sunday, August 9, 2009
Job Posting: Fanshawe College
Prior: Job Posting.
Friday, August 7, 2009
New Ombuds at University of Colorado at Colorado Springs
MIT Ombuds to Speak at University of Arizona
Thursday, August 6, 2009
Job Posting: National Institutes of Health
Related posts: Perspective on Ethical Standards for Federal Mediators and Ombuds; NIH Ombuds Addresses the Complexities of Race-Related Conflict; New Ombuds at American Red Cross.
Update: FOIA Ombuds Ready to Hire Staff
Prior post: FOIA Ombuds Appointed.
Montana State University Posts Annual Report
Sunday, August 2, 2009
University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign President Calls for Admissions Ombuds
Related post: Student Trustee Seeks Reinstatement of Ombuds at U. Illinois Campus.
Progress Briefing from New DoD Ombuds
Related posts: Department of Defense Announces First Ombuds for Inspector General.